Why a 5.0 rating usually means nobody has stayed

Airbnb ratings are compressed into almost nothing: seventy percent of the market sits in the top three tenths of a point, so 4.8 — which reads like a good score — is in fact below average here. Worse, a perfect score mostly signals absence of evidence rather than quality. This page shows the problem, then the correction every ranking on this site uses instead, and finishes on what a badge is actually worth.

Median rating
the published average
Weighted
credibility-adjusted
Median reviews
Thinly reviewed
under 5 reviews
Carry a badge
Guest favorite premium
nightly, vs no badge

The rating distribution, charted once to show it is unusable

Every rated listing, bucketed at the 0.1 Airbnb publishes

Loading

A perfect score is mostly an empty one

Share rated exactly 5.0, by how many reviews the listing has

Loading

What a badge is worth

Measured inside one scrape, where the field is reliable

Loading

The leaderboard, ranked honestly

By weighted score, with at least ten reviews — so it cannot be won by a listing nobody has stayed in

Loading